diff --git a/Common/UI/View.cpp b/Common/UI/View.cpp
index f18810233947..218198d36b18 100644
--- a/Common/UI/View.cpp
+++ b/Common/UI/View.cpp
@@ -1590,20 +1590,27 @@ void Slider::Clamp() {
 
 void Slider::Draw(UIContext &dc) {
 	bool focus = HasFocus();
-	uint32_t linecolor = dc.theme->itemStyle.fgColor;
-	Style knobStyle = (down_ || focus) ? dc.theme->itemStyle : dc.theme->popupStyle;
+	uint32_t sliderColor;
+
+	if (down_) {
+		sliderColor = popupStyle_ ? dc.theme->popupSliderFocusedColor : dc.theme->itemDownStyle.fgColor;
+	} else if (focus) {
+		sliderColor = popupStyle_ ? dc.theme->popupSliderFocusedColor : dc.theme->itemFocusedStyle.fgColor;
+	} else {
+		sliderColor = popupStyle_ ? dc.theme->popupSliderColor : dc.theme->itemStyle.fgColor;
+	}
 
 	float knobX = ((float)(*value_) - minValue_) / (maxValue_ - minValue_) * (bounds_.w - paddingLeft_ - paddingRight_) + (bounds_.x + paddingLeft_);
-	dc.FillRect(Drawable(linecolor), Bounds(bounds_.x + paddingLeft_, bounds_.centerY() - 2, knobX - (bounds_.x + paddingLeft_), 4));
+	dc.FillRect(Drawable(sliderColor), Bounds(bounds_.x + paddingLeft_, bounds_.centerY() - 2, knobX - (bounds_.x + paddingLeft_), 4));
 	dc.FillRect(Drawable(0xFF808080), Bounds(knobX, bounds_.centerY() - 2, (bounds_.x + bounds_.w - paddingRight_ - knobX), 4));
-	dc.Draw()->DrawImage(dc.theme->sliderKnob, knobX, bounds_.centerY(), 1.0f, knobStyle.fgColor, ALIGN_CENTER);
+	dc.Draw()->DrawImage(dc.theme->sliderKnob, knobX, bounds_.centerY(), 1.0f, sliderColor, ALIGN_CENTER);
 	char temp[64];
 	if (showPercent_)
 		snprintf(temp, sizeof(temp), "%d%%", *value_);
 	else
 		snprintf(temp, sizeof(temp), "%d", *value_);
 	dc.SetFontStyle(dc.theme->uiFont);
-	dc.DrawText(temp, bounds_.x2() - 22, bounds_.centerY(), dc.theme->popupStyle.fgColor, ALIGN_CENTER | FLAG_DYNAMIC_ASCII);
+	dc.DrawText(temp, bounds_.x2() - 22, bounds_.centerY(), sliderColor, ALIGN_CENTER | FLAG_DYNAMIC_ASCII);
 }
 
 std::string Slider::DescribeText() const {
@@ -1743,17 +1750,24 @@ void SliderFloat::Clamp() {
 
 void SliderFloat::Draw(UIContext &dc) {
 	bool focus = HasFocus();
-	uint32_t linecolor = dc.theme->itemStyle.fgColor;
-	Style knobStyle = (down_ || focus) ? dc.theme->itemStyle : dc.theme->popupStyle;
+	uint32_t sliderColor;
+
+	if (down_) {
+		sliderColor = popupStyle_ ? dc.theme->popupSliderFocusedColor : dc.theme->itemDownStyle.fgColor;
+	} else if (focus) {
+		sliderColor = popupStyle_ ? dc.theme->popupSliderFocusedColor : dc.theme->itemFocusedStyle.fgColor;
+	} else {
+		sliderColor = popupStyle_ ? dc.theme->popupSliderColor : dc.theme->itemStyle.fgColor;
+	}
 
 	float knobX = (*value_ - minValue_) / (maxValue_ - minValue_) * (bounds_.w - paddingLeft_ - paddingRight_) + (bounds_.x + paddingLeft_);
-	dc.FillRect(Drawable(linecolor), Bounds(bounds_.x + paddingLeft_, bounds_.centerY() - 2, knobX - (bounds_.x + paddingLeft_), 4));
+	dc.FillRect(Drawable(sliderColor), Bounds(bounds_.x + paddingLeft_, bounds_.centerY() - 2, knobX - (bounds_.x + paddingLeft_), 4));
 	dc.FillRect(Drawable(0xFF808080), Bounds(knobX, bounds_.centerY() - 2, (bounds_.x + bounds_.w - paddingRight_ - knobX), 4));
-	dc.Draw()->DrawImage(dc.theme->sliderKnob, knobX, bounds_.centerY(), 1.0f, knobStyle.fgColor, ALIGN_CENTER);
+	dc.Draw()->DrawImage(dc.theme->sliderKnob, knobX, bounds_.centerY(), 1.0f, sliderColor, ALIGN_CENTER);
 	char temp[64];
 	snprintf(temp, sizeof(temp), "%0.2f", *value_);
 	dc.SetFontStyle(dc.theme->uiFont);
-	dc.DrawText(temp, bounds_.x2() - 22, bounds_.centerY(), dc.theme->popupStyle.fgColor, ALIGN_CENTER);
+	dc.DrawText(temp, bounds_.x2() - 22, bounds_.centerY(), sliderColor, ALIGN_CENTER);
 }
 
 std::string SliderFloat::DescribeText() const {
diff --git a/Common/UI/View.h b/Common/UI/View.h
index a63fd34e6094..09f5762ed42a 100644
--- a/Common/UI/View.h
+++ b/Common/UI/View.h
@@ -116,6 +116,8 @@ struct Theme {
 
 	uint32_t backgroundColor;
 	uint32_t scrollbarColor;
+	uint32_t popupSliderColor;
+	uint32_t popupSliderFocusedColor;
 };
 
 // The four cardinal directions should be enough, plus Prev/Next in "element order".
diff --git a/UI/Theme.cpp b/UI/Theme.cpp
index 9ab731dcfbd1..1e15f1419e5e 100644
--- a/UI/Theme.cpp
+++ b/UI/Theme.cpp
@@ -59,6 +59,8 @@ struct ThemeInfo {
 	uint32_t uCollapsibleHeaderStyleBg = 0x55000000;
 	uint32_t uBackgroundColor = 0xFF754D24;
 	uint32_t uScrollbarColor = 0x80FFFFFF;
+	uint32_t uPopupSliderColor = 0xFFFFFFFF;
+	uint32_t uPopupSliderFocusedColor = 0xFFEDC24C;
 
 	std::string sUIAtlas = "ui_atlas";
 
@@ -154,6 +156,8 @@ static void LoadThemeInfo(const std::vector<Path> &directories) {
 				section.Get("CollapsibleHeaderStyleBg", &info.uCollapsibleHeaderStyleBg, info.uItemStyleBg);
 				section.Get("BackgroundColor", &info.uBackgroundColor, info.uBackgroundColor);
 				section.Get("ScrollbarColor", &info.uScrollbarColor, info.uScrollbarColor);
+				section.Get("PopupSliderColor", &info.uPopupSliderColor, info.uPopupSliderColor);
+				section.Get("PopupSliderFocusedColor", &info.uPopupSliderFocusedColor, info.uPopupSliderFocusedColor);
 
 				std::string tmpPath;
 				section.Get("UIAtlas", &tmpPath, "");
@@ -263,6 +267,9 @@ void UpdateTheme(UIContext *ctx) {
 	ui_theme.backgroundColor = themeInfo.uBackgroundColor;
 	ui_theme.scrollbarColor = themeInfo.uScrollbarColor;
 
+	ui_theme.popupSliderColor = themeInfo.uPopupSliderColor;
+	ui_theme.popupSliderFocusedColor = themeInfo.uPopupSliderFocusedColor;
+
 	// Load any missing atlas metadata (the images are loaded from UIContext).
 	LoadAtlasMetadata(ui_atlas, (themeInfo.sUIAtlas + ".meta").c_str(), true);
 #if !(PPSSPP_PLATFORM(WINDOWS) || PPSSPP_PLATFORM(ANDROID))
diff --git a/assets/themes/defaultthemes.ini b/assets/themes/defaultthemes.ini
index c8e8a0a14fe7..2d681f000ff7 100644
--- a/assets/themes/defaultthemes.ini
+++ b/assets/themes/defaultthemes.ini
@@ -22,6 +22,8 @@ TooltipStyleFg = "#FFFFFFFF"
 TooltipStyleBg = "#303030C0"
 BackgroundColor = "#244D75FF"
 ScrollbarColor = "#FFFFFF80"
+PopupSliderColor = "#FFFFFFFF"
+PopupSliderFocusedColor = "#4CC2EDFF"
 UIAtlas = "../ui_atlas"
 
 # Colors are either in the format "#RGBA" or 0xABGR (e.g. green is "#00FF00FF" or 0xFF00FF00)
@@ -52,4 +54,6 @@ TooltipStyleFg = "#FFFFFFFF"
 TooltipStyleBg = "#303030C0"
 BackgroundColor = "#000000FF"
 ScrollbarColor = "#FFFFFF80"
+PopupSliderColor = "#FFFFFFFF"
+PopupSliderFocusedColor = "#3799bdFF"
 UIAtlas = "../ui_atlas"